Ya if he has the same stats and is on the magic then he’s all star
Organic_Prompt_2069
easily
Nervous-Astronaut244
Scottie is > Paolo and Paolo will probably be an all star this year so i think so.
mMounirM
we don’t even know if Paolo is making it
LegendKingX
Yes absolutely don’t worry Scottie will be an all star soon enough
n3moh0es
yea that’s how it usually works
King_ofCanada
Raps fans – in the same convo – do you think Randle gets in again? I think he deserves it.
Ok_Apricot_9880
The team needs a better record.
2against1
No
bustthelease
Yes
Dareal6
Yes
MstrNixx
Scottie and Paolo as a Duo would be crazy
anismatic
I think recency has affected his claim. If he was playing the same way he was before the trade, absolutely. He’s been pretty lackluster since then (at least as far as shooting numbers go), which is kind of expected with the shake-up in the team’s direction. Hopefully he picks it up and can shoot for All-NBA baby!
midnightmunchiez
He’d be an all star if he was on an American team.
mxgicjohnson
Yeah. It’s pretty ridiculous
We can only pray Randle or Paolo get snubbed really really hard. If there’s an injury reserve spot then he will get it.
Delicious_Fee574
Yes winning matters
Basketball_Reference
Here’s the Stathead tool used, if anyone is interested 🙂
I would say Paolo is also the more popular player and recency bias will play a factor. I do think Scottie deserves to be an all star this season though.
SnooPineapples6099
He’d be an all star if people voted for him.
Canada has one team.
An entire country failed this man.
jsleepy
***on an American team. FTFY and yes.
MegaMaax
Yeah raptors players get zero recognition. Everybody is hyping up pascal now that he’s in Indiana but when he was a raptor he was always called overrated and got slandered by NBA fans. 🤦♂️
I think he would but unfortunately I think the coaches take how good a team is into consideration when voting
Stillwiththe
Yeah he’s better than Paolo but if it’s between the two Paolo gets it because he’s been a #1 and they’ve been better
plugged97
Yes. Similar situation as to why Jalen Brunson is considered an all star lock, yet Tyrese Maxey might miss out despite having almost identical numbers. Big difference between being ‘the man’ in New York versus Embiid’s sidekick
rebay1607
Why are we comparing a third year player to a second year player? We should be comparing second year Barnes to second year Paolo – this is a really misleading graphic imo
Right-Beautiful7631
I feel like he has enough respect around the league that he could be voted in by coaches still
CanadianGroose
If the raptors were in 8th instead of 12th, I think so yeah.
gamer-at-heart-23
Most definitely, NBA doesn’t say it but they do it based more on team record. You should see some stars who didn’t make the all-star team cause their team wasnt good. Examples are young, Lillard, Booker, Beal, etc. Beal avged 30ppg one year and absolutely got robbed
guffzillar
If you are being fair, would he average those numbers on a better team
Massive_Secretary658
He needs to get that ppg up a bit
pakattack91
Crazy how much Scottie blows him out in advance stats…which is not a knock on Banchero but how special Scottie is
Guyanese_boi81492
Scottie needs to be consistent first before he gets all star nod…
N0minal
Of course. If he was on a team with solid role players and good spacers there’s no question.
BurzyGuerrero
Scottie is the #1, he doesn’t get the “better team” excuse.
If Scotties team was better, he would be an all star because Canada would vote for him.
Scottie is not a star Canada-wide yet. He’s just a guy who hasn’t had success.
Get into the playoffs and Canada will support him.
Icy-Lime-9760
Absolutely
CodFederal4769
But, would Scottie have the same stats if he was on a team like Boston, Minnesota, Milwaukee, Denver, 76ers, Clipper etc? I think his stats would be a lot lower. And he would be the 2nd or 3rd best player on all these teams.
RasenRendan
Yes
TurboByte24
Better team? Raptors is a Canada team and only half a million voted for him.
40 Comments
Ya if he has the same stats and is on the magic then he’s all star
easily
Scottie is > Paolo and Paolo will probably be an all star this year so i think so.
we don’t even know if Paolo is making it
Yes absolutely don’t worry Scottie will be an all star soon enough
yea that’s how it usually works
Raps fans – in the same convo – do you think Randle gets in again? I think he deserves it.
The team needs a better record.
No
Yes
Yes
Scottie and Paolo as a Duo would be crazy
I think recency has affected his claim. If he was playing the same way he was before the trade, absolutely. He’s been pretty lackluster since then (at least as far as shooting numbers go), which is kind of expected with the shake-up in the team’s direction. Hopefully he picks it up and can shoot for All-NBA baby!
He’d be an all star if he was on an American team.
Yeah. It’s pretty ridiculous
We can only pray Randle or Paolo get snubbed really really hard. If there’s an injury reserve spot then he will get it.
Yes winning matters
Here’s the Stathead tool used, if anyone is interested 🙂
[https://stathead.com/tiny/cPoXW](https://stathead.com/tiny/cPoXW)
He would be an all star if we voted for him
I would say Paolo is also the more popular player and recency bias will play a factor. I do think Scottie deserves to be an all star this season though.
He’d be an all star if people voted for him.
Canada has one team.
An entire country failed this man.
***on an American team. FTFY and yes.
Yeah raptors players get zero recognition. Everybody is hyping up pascal now that he’s in Indiana but when he was a raptor he was always called overrated and got slandered by NBA fans. 🤦♂️
https://preview.redd.it/n7r22zf7ruec1.png?width=1320&format=png&auto=webp&s=f48d263dba2d29b87c6ef55761ccec5a6bbc9914
I think he would but unfortunately I think the coaches take how good a team is into consideration when voting
Yeah he’s better than Paolo but if it’s between the two Paolo gets it because he’s been a #1 and they’ve been better
Yes. Similar situation as to why Jalen Brunson is considered an all star lock, yet Tyrese Maxey might miss out despite having almost identical numbers. Big difference between being ‘the man’ in New York versus Embiid’s sidekick
Why are we comparing a third year player to a second year player? We should be comparing second year Barnes to second year Paolo – this is a really misleading graphic imo
I feel like he has enough respect around the league that he could be voted in by coaches still
If the raptors were in 8th instead of 12th, I think so yeah.
Most definitely, NBA doesn’t say it but they do it based more on team record. You should see some stars who didn’t make the all-star team cause their team wasnt good. Examples are young, Lillard, Booker, Beal, etc. Beal avged 30ppg one year and absolutely got robbed
If you are being fair, would he average those numbers on a better team
He needs to get that ppg up a bit
Crazy how much Scottie blows him out in advance stats…which is not a knock on Banchero but how special Scottie is
Scottie needs to be consistent first before he gets all star nod…
Of course. If he was on a team with solid role players and good spacers there’s no question.
Scottie is the #1, he doesn’t get the “better team” excuse.
If Scotties team was better, he would be an all star because Canada would vote for him.
Scottie is not a star Canada-wide yet. He’s just a guy who hasn’t had success.
Get into the playoffs and Canada will support him.
Absolutely
But, would Scottie have the same stats if he was on a team like Boston, Minnesota, Milwaukee, Denver, 76ers, Clipper etc? I think his stats would be a lot lower. And he would be the 2nd or 3rd best player on all these teams.
Yes
Better team? Raptors is a Canada team and only half a million voted for him.