Mastodon
@Oklahoma City Thunder

Who’s Better: Shai vs All Time NBA Greats



Who’s Better: Shai vs All Time NBA Greats

Where does Shai Gilgeous Alexander stack up versus All Time Greats

#PickaSide #ShaiGilgeousAlexander #OKCThunder

44 Comments

  1. Joel extremely bias here:
    No, Westbrook team was NOT even close to Harden in 2017, he had TWO 6th Men of the year coming off the bench while Russ couldn't even come off the floor. His 2nd best player had zero playoff experience (Oladipo) and his 3rd became unplayable (Kanter).

    Russ lead the league in scoring, lead the league in clutch points and 2nd in assist and had legit NO roster.

  2. He doesn't have a ring because he averages 13 points in the final games of his series in his career. He just cant stop choking.

  3. This number shi be blowing me, era matters, eye test matters, the comp ur going against matters, CONTEXT matters 😂

  4. I’m sorry it’s no way I’m taking sga over embiid I’m sorry. Idc if dawg had 5 rings 😂Ik what my eyes see

  5. How do you say shai has less turnovers and yet passes less 😂. Shai only has better efficiency and slightly better defense. He's in no way a better scorer or passer, I don't even think Shai has better handles than James Harden lol

  6. Give me peak harden over sga cmon bruh. 36 ppg? And a way better passer. Yall gotta stop with the recency bias

  7. Regular season, SGA and Harden at that peaks are really close offensively. SGA is a better defender although Harden is underrated. In the playoffs, it just isn’t close. Take SGA all day

  8. So what what we're saying is Shai isn't as good cause he has a better squad? I think I'm living in the multiverse now cause that makes no sense

  9. The hate for harden is something I will never understand fr. It’s like he did something to yall personally or something.

  10. Sga just passed wilts record for most consecutive 20 point games. He also just dropped 71 points of offense with 0 turnovers against the nuggets. He is one of the most consistent and efficient guards of all time. Also nash is way closer to sga then Harden is.

  11. Shai still needs to get there but players with at least 2 titles and 2 MVPs in 9 total:
    Jordan
    Lebron
    Kareem
    Bill Russell
    Wilt
    Magic
    Bird
    Duncan
    Steph

    Thats the whole list and Shai might join that list soon.

  12. Dude I’m sorry man but if u have to literally make up scenarios and give harden extra accolades because you “think” he should won it then what are we doing 😂😂😂😂. Also the minute u deadass said u think harden shoulda won mvp in 2015 over steph i had to just pause and laugh 😂😂😂. Harden was great but when u take the shoulda coulda woulda route all ur doing is making harden look worse. It’s laughable to just say harden shoulda been 3x mvp, 3x champion. How far from reality do u have to drift to make harden be better than Shai lol

  13. Harden – 6x 1st team all nba, 6x top 5 mvp, 3x 30 ppg in 17 seasons
    Shai – 4x 1st team all nba, 4x top 5 MVP, 4x 30 ppg in 8 seasons

  14. Kawhi “out 6-8 weeks” Leonard had a higher peak than Shai?? He hit that one shot against Philly and beat the hospital Warriors wtf 😂

  15. How on this planet earth SGA is not on the top 100 are we fucking kidding me? Do anyone realize that Shai is the only player that is always the best player whenever he is on the floor nobody on his team every out scored his offensively on every other team their best player isn’t always there best score. We have lots of haters mann

  16. The guy with 2 MVPs 2 Finals MVPs and averaging 30 off 50% for 4 straight seasons would still be behind notorious playoff dropper James Harden. What are we doing

  17. How can yall not bring up defense? Even if Shai has a great defense around him he himself is a way better defender than harden

  18. Ngl I’m not hearing Shai better offensively he’s not harden was a amazing playmaker and makes his teammates so much better so I’m taking harden I’m sorry if harden had dort caruso Chet jdub and hartenstien on defense come on man

  19. SGA has already surpassed Kobe. About to double him up in MVP. 4 straight 30+ppg with 50%+ shooting seasons. Kobe has never done that. Not once.

  20. Hardens nerves kick in in the playoffs, he hasn’t handled that clutch well. There’s a reel with Kobe and McGrady saying what Harden is doing will work in the regular season but in the playoffs he’ll never win a championship with that style

  21. Bleacher report leaving Shai off that top 100 was the most egregious thing I’ve ever seen, and made me stop taking bleacher report seriously, considering they put current players on that list who have not come close to accomplishing what Shai has accomplished. The bias on that list was incredibly evident

  22. Moved on from talking about Harden for 5 minutes and then bro brings it up AGAIN just to bring up more absurd what if questions.

  23. Shai wouldnt let his team miss 29 3s in a row to choke a game 7 vs gsw. Harden is a regular season warrior much less efficient too

  24. I find it funny how they keep saying “2rings 2 finals mvp” can the man actually do it first? NBA community did this same dumb shit with jokic Giannis Jayson Tatum. Then God forbid Shai looses or a key player on his team gets hurt then he gets slandered smfh

  25. Also in terms of gardens MVPs Imo he should win in 15 19 along with the mvp he won in 18. 17 is debatable but it’s really hard to argue against Russ that season.

Write A Comment